A few opinions on the character art.
3 posters
Page 1 of 1
A few opinions on the character art.
Hi, I figured I should speak up for a friend of mine, as well as myself, so we could voice our opinions on the character art. I am basing this reasoning off of the promotional teaser art. (Great drawings, by the way. I squee everytime I see them.)
We love the character art, no doubt, though there were a few things that irked us that I thought we should to mention:
I don't mean for you guys to take this criticism harshly, though I thought I'd drop second opinions before it's too late. Regardless you decide to change them or not, I want to thank you for hearing us out.
We love the character art, no doubt, though there were a few things that irked us that I thought we should to mention:
- He is not a fan of the short Twilight hair. My own speculation is that both are included in the story, but he thinks that the short hair is "very tomboyish". Take that as you will, we don't know the whole story.
- Pinkie Pie could have slightly longer hair. It's a tad too short, in our opinion.
- Rainbow Dash's collar is buttoned up, unlike Applejack's. If anybody, shouldn't Rainbow Dash be the one with the open collar? Speaking of Rainbow Dash, is it me, or are her eyes a bit jagged in the teaser picture?
- I noticed that Applejack is wearing a different uniform, most likely implying that she is the oldest amongst them all. I'm pretty curious-shouldn't Fluttershy be older as well?
I don't mean for you guys to take this criticism harshly, though I thought I'd drop second opinions before it's too late. Regardless you decide to change them or not, I want to thank you for hearing us out.
Potentialing- Posts : 30
Join date : 2012-08-26
Location : Confirmed
Re: A few opinions on the character art.
I believe that they said the teaser wasn't in any way a final product, and that they would probably be changing it later on. They'll probably have to, anyways, since as the stories develop differently, they'll probably need a new art form, depending.
Though I'm not really one to post on behalf of Starswirl. Just making conjecture.
Though I'm not really one to post on behalf of Starswirl. Just making conjecture.
EggtasticTaco- Posts : 3
Join date : 2012-08-29
Age : 30
Location : Under your bed
Re: A few opinions on the character art.
You'll see Twilight's (mostly) final character design very soon. EDIT: OH LOOK AT THAT!Potentialing wrote:
- He is not a fan of the short Twilight hair. My own speculation is that both are included in the story, but he thinks that the short hair is "very tomboyish". Take that as you will, we don't know the whole story.
Pinkie's hair got the most response for that teaser image. It's already been changed up, though the design is still probably going to have a few more revisions.Potentialing wrote:Pinkie Pie could have slightly longer hair. It's a tad too short, in our opinion.
Possibly, but Dash is more comfortable in her gym uniform anyway...Potentialing wrote:Rainbow Dash's collar is buttoned up, unlike Applejack's. If anybody, shouldn't Rainbow Dash be the one with the open collar?
The game assets are redrawn from scratch, not copied off of the teaser image. If there's any wonkiness, it won't be there in the finished product.Potentialing wrote:Speaking of Rainbow Dash, is it me, or are her eyes a bit jagged in the teaser picture?
AJ isn't wearing a different uniform, she's breaking the dress code.Potentialing wrote:I noticed that Applejack is wearing a different uniform, most likely implying that she is the oldest amongst them all.
They're all in the same year of school, though they may not be the same ages.Potentialing wrote:I'm pretty curious-shouldn't Fluttershy be older as well?
I'm feeling talkative today, apparently.
Re: A few opinions on the character art.
Thanks for clearing that all up for us! Those Twilight sketches look great, by the way!
Potentialing- Posts : 30
Join date : 2012-08-26
Location : Confirmed
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
|
|